My first song

2 messages Options
Embed this post
Permalink
ScotiaTheOne

My first song

Reply Threaded More More options
Print post
Permalink
Hi, been playin guitar for about a year, and thought Id give songwriting a go... so here you go. Feedback welcome, the more honest the better, and even if its just to change a word/phrase. I dont yet have a tune for it, but ill have a play about. Thanks

In a crowded room I stand alone.
The more I look the less I know,
tryin hard to make sense of it all
I venture out, in search for more.
If only I could find the door
ill at ease I make an awkward call.

Memories are precious things
I love the laughs and tears they bring
Sat at the kitchen table getting high.
But changes they are comin fast
He said 'you cant repeat the past'
I quite agree and wouldnt like to try


I've felt love win over lust,
I've realised since that I was just
chasing shadows. Well, it meant the world to me.
Those days seem like a world away
in fact it was just yesterday
There's still so many things I'd like to see

An open mind, well that's a start
Friends with views a world apart
There's not an easy answer I can give.
What seeds of thought can you truly sow?
How high can you watch them grow
and how much can you say you know
When you've only got a hundred years to live?
iralarry

Re: My first song

Reply Threaded More More options
Print post
Permalink
Hey:

I will be frank with you.  There are some elements here that will work, eventually.  There is nothing original in thought here, or at least expressed as original.  All these ideas have been visited a thousand times.  It appears you are young and I do not want to discourage your creative penchant but this seems it came forth in a matter of minutes or maybe an hour.  These thoughts are disjointed and thus possess not cohesive unity.  

Verse 1: you talk about feeling alone

Verse 2: Memories and getting high

Verse 3: Love and lust and there is an ambiguity in what meant the world to you.  Love over lust or realizing you were chasing shadows, not an apt metaphor for lust, at least in my opinion.

Verse 4: An open mind, well that's a start
            Friends with views a world apart

That is the best in here.  And what answer?  There is no question.  I see the thought but in a song there is no time to decipher or make one think even a little.  

The seeds thing is old too.  

I understand that you are new to guitar and you SHOULD NOT give it up.  THis should also not discourage you but force you to dig deeper into your life experience, find more literate vernacular and search out the best music that supports these thought as written long before you were born.
Example: Joni Mitchell-Court and Spark-Peoples Parties.
              Moody Blues-Seventh Sojourn-Kinghts in White Satin
              ANY BOB DYLAN.  
Just read the lyrics, forget the music for now.  The words came first, likely, anyway.

Good luck, don't be discouraged.  Even the best writers rewrite sometimes a dozen times before it is right.  You can not possibly expect your first to be great or even barely good right out of the gate, really!

Larry Mayer
SI, NY